Pizza restaurants

Pizza Cellar

4.5 729 reviews 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM 3015 State Hwy 176, Rockaway Beach, MO 65740, United States

Discover this place

Pizza Cellar, located at 3015 State Hwy 176 in Rockaway Beach, MO, is a cherished gem that encapsulates the essence of a classic small-town pizzeria. Customers rave about the delicious pizza and friendly service, making this spot an ideal choice for both family dinners and romantic outings. As noted by long-time patron Johnathan Stokesberry, this establishment has remained consistent over the decades, delivering the same delightful flavors and warm hospitality that families have enjoyed for over 30 years.

The unique atmosphere of the restaurant, set in a cozy cellar, adds to its charm. Laura Martinson emphasizes the appealing vibe and the delectable lunch options available, while Jessica Swofford praises not only the pizza but also the impressive salads and the nostalgic ambiance.

Galen Douglas Heritage fondly recalls his childhood visits, highlighting that the enduring quality of Pizza Cellar makes it a beloved destination for families. With friendly staff and a commitment to great food, it’s easy to see why diners often consider Pizza Cellar their go-to spot. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this pizza haven promises a culinary experience that’s rich in flavor and warm in spirit.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Fireplace
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Historic
Trendy

Crowd

Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Pizza Cellar before visiting.

Reviews for Pizza Cellar

4.5

729 reviews

100%

19%

Review highlights

Based on 729 reviews

Pizza Cellar consistently receives praise for its warm, small-town charm and nostalgic atmosphere, often highlighted by its unique cellar location. Reviewers appreciate the restaurant’s long-standing commitment to quality, with many noting the food remains as delicious as it was decades ago, making it a beloved spot for both locals and visitors. The pizza, complemented by well-regarded salads, is frequently described as exceptional. Additionally, the friendly and attentive service stands out, contributing to a welcoming environment ideal for family dinners or casual outings. Patrons also value the continuity in ownership and management, which enhances the authentic, unchanged experience over the years. Overall, Pizza Cellar is recognized for blending great food, consistent quality, and a personable atmosphere that resonates with both longstanding customers and newcomers alike.

Sidney “Siddy” Hill

Jul 03, 2025

Just a good ole small town pizza joint on the lake! Everyone who is there is so kind! The food is great! And the service is amazing! Great for a family dinner or a date night!

Johnathan Stokesberry

Jul 03, 2025

A little late on this post but This place is amazing and just like I remember it. I have been coming here for over 30 years. Brought the family on their first trip to Branson this last Christmas. I have raved for years how I have not found any pizza that is remotely close to how good this place is. Let alone, I was super happy to see the same ownership/management was there as it was when I was growing up. Pretty awesome for the kids to play same arcade games I did growing up and the hospitality shown made everyone from my wife and kids to the in-laws feel just so at home. Father in law even stated he would make this a weekly Friday night spot if we lived in the area. Planning another family vacation in November and everyone is talking about how they want to come back and enjoy the amazing food and hospitality the Pizza Cellar has to offer.

Laura Martinson

Jun 21, 2025

Made a stop here for lunch while waiting to get into our Airbnb. So glad we did. The pizza was delicious! Staff was friendly. It is located in a cellar/basement which made for a neat atmosphere. Highly recommend!

Jessica Swofford

Jun 06, 2025

The BEST pizza I've had in a long time. The salads are spectacular. Amazing service, friendly people and nostalgic atmosphere.

Galen Douglas Heritage

May 11, 2025

I used to come here every year as a kid while my family visited for the 4th of July. We would stay at Steven's Cottages and often walk over to the Cellar in the evenings for pizza and arcade games. This place has not changed a bit in 35 years! And in a constantly changing world, I really appreciate that.

Angie Froese

May 03, 2025

I give this place 5 starts because this is our kind of place. It is located in the basement and is dark and danky but pizza is fantastic and the staff a friendly. You can still smoke on the bar side but not the restaurant part even though there is some overlap. It’s just a fun place to go for a cold beer and some good pizza.

Joshua Evans

Apr 23, 2025

This local Pizza place is great! We have gotten take out for 10yrs. So glad we have a local place that's stayed open this long. Pizza and wings are great! The staff is super friendly and a great chef! Thanks for serving the community! If you live in Forsyth, definitely worth the short drive. Casey's doesn't compare and isn't truly local.

Paige Dryden

Mar 29, 2025

This place is awesome!!! When you walk in you go down stairs to a cellar / bar. Chelsea and Dennis, were absolutely wonderful and funny! The pizza was good but the wings are fantastic and totally worth price!! We will be back probably every time we visit! We had a great time here!!!